Why We Let Our Kids Pick One Room to Redecorate and How It Turned Out
I had assumed the solution to our bedroom complaints would be more bedrooms. We live in a modest three-bedroom house in Brisbane with four people, and our eleven-year-old, Mia, and eight-year-old, Leo, share a room that has become the setting for arguments about closed doors, lost socks and whose turn it is to tidy. I wanted walls that did not shake whenever Lego landed at half past six in the evening.
What changed was the way we made decisions. Rather than squeeze two personalities into separate bedrooms, we offered them ownership of one space and a say in what happened there. The kids chose the room, the colours and the layout; my husband, Andrew, and I handled the budget, safety and the parts requiring adult tools. That division of responsibility felt fairer than adults dictating a playroom they still had to clean.
We set three limits: one room, a budget of six hundred dollars and a space that had to support schoolwork as well as play. It had to earn its keep on an ordinary school-holiday Tuesday, not merely look good in photographs. We also agreed that any money saved or spent would be recorded openly, because children notice when a promise becomes vague.
A few months on, the project has produced green paint, two mismatched desks and a surprising amount of learning about compromise. The shared bedroom still exists, yet it feels calmer because the study has absorbed the competing needs of homework, construction and quiet reading. Best of all, our children now experience a home that responds to their ideas without surrendering to every passing wish.
The bedroom argument that began it
The final push came after dinner, when Mia announced that she was too old to share a bedroom with a brother who borrowed her charger. Leo countered that she monopolised the bed nearest the window and used his pillow as a backrest. These disputes had become daily background noise. Andrew and I could keep offering sibling advice, but we were really dealing with a lack of space and control.
So we offered a different bargain. Each child could select one room in the house to redecorate, and they could work together on it while we kept their shared bedroom for sleeping. We would not add furniture to the crowded bedroom or turn the guest room into a storage depot. The new space needed to solve a real problem, not create two more reasons to negotiate.
I kept a Sahm diary years ago, and looking back at those ordinary entries reminded me how much family life lives in small routines rather than polished milestones. We were not trying to build a children's showroom. We wanted somewhere Mia could complete homework without Leo stacking every available brick, and somewhere Leo could build without being told his noise was a problem.
Letting the children choose the space
The children inspected every option like tiny property valuers. Mia rejected the front guest room because it lacked a proper desk, while Leo liked its large cupboard. They eventually chose the small study at the back, which had good bones but little personality: a wide window, a tired desk and a door that closed. It sat away from the bedrooms, so noise here would be less likely to keep us awake.
The plan was a shared study and playroom, not two pretend bedrooms. Mia claimed the window side for a desk and reading chair; Leo chose the wall opposite for building and drawing. Between them they wanted a book shelf, two large storage units and one long surface for shared projects. Keeping their sleeping arrangements unchanged mattered because we did not have another bedroom to offer.
We agreed on a family budget of $600, using money the children had saved plus a contribution from us. They could choose two wall colours, but the room had to remain usable for adults and older visitors. Andrew reserved final say on electrical work and furniture stability. In return, I promised not to add a project that existed mainly because I wanted a satisfying before-and-after photograph.
Paint plans and sibling compromises
Paint exposed a difference we had somehow failed to anticipate. Mia wanted deep emerald walls, while Leo wanted sunshine yellow with black stripes. Neither colour suited the other child's corner, and both children had strong feelings about fairness. We compromised with deep green below the picture rail and warm cream above it, adding a mustard chair and yellow desk lamps to acknowledge Leo without turning the room into a paint shop.
We tested sample pots on cardboard for two days, checking them under morning light and the warmer glow of our evening lamp. That practical step prevented an argument I could otherwise have intensified. The window also needed proper curtains for an Australian summer, especially the fierce afternoon sun, while the room's occasional damp patch meant we should avoid crowding it with too much furniture.
The finished layout kept desks separate but put the craft table in the middle, where a shared project could expand. We left one narrow wall open for displaying work rather than filling it with identical storage cubes. For another perspective on purposeful room layouts, I came across a thoughtful design reflection while planning, and the reminder to begin with daily use helped us resist buying things simply because the room looked bare.
Shopping and decorating on a sensible budget
Shopping was divided by task rather than crammed into one exhausting trip. We bought primer, brushes and rollers at Bunnings, inexpensive storage cubes at Kmart and a sturdy secondhand desk from a Salvos op shop. In the back of our car, the desk looked slightly ridiculous beside our groceries. It was also the room's most useful piece and cost less than a takeaway family dinner.
The practical approach to family homes I enjoy on Motley Mama suited the way we handled the budget: decoration had to support real routines. I showed the children where the money was going, including the gap between an item's sticker price and the small extras we would need. That honesty took some sparkle out of the shopping, but it made the final bill easier to accept.
The work took three weekends: one for painting, one for assembling the desks and shelves, and one for textiles and finishing touches. The children sanded pieces and chose the fabric while Andrew and I handled cutting and tools. We spent $487 in total and put the remaining $113 into a jar for repairs and replacements. The jar felt more sensible than declaring the room finished when the first chair developed a wobble.
Giving the room a deeper purpose
The room also borrowed ideas from our family Advent tradition, when we set aside time each December to anticipate Christmas together. We kept the decorations restrained: paper stars, a small wooden manger and a candle on a high shelf. The children made the stars, and the plain cream wall became a backdrop for their uneven shapes and metallic tape.
Faith has always been part of our home, but I did not want the new room to feel like a religious display. We placed one Scripture card beside the book shelf, near Matthew 19:14, where Jesus welcomes the children and reminds us not to treat them as interruptions. I prayed over the room before we painted. It was a quiet moment, not a ceremony for the photographs.
Leo read the card aloud each morning after breakfast, although he admitted that some of it still made little sense. Mia tucked a folded prayer into her desk drawer. Those small actions mattered more to me than coordinated devotion. The room now holds our family's ordinary Tuesday alongside something we believe matters, and it does so without pretending to be perfect.
Life during the first school holiday
The first school holiday tested the arrangement almost immediately. By 9 am, Lego covered the shared table, glitter had reached the curtains and both children wanted the single craft space. When sorting the toy overflow, I used our family toy guide as a starting point for deciding what stayed out and what went into labelled tubs. Favourites survived; duplicates and forgotten items went to charity.
We established simple rules after the second noisy morning. The craft table belonged to whoever booked it, headphones were welcome for focused work, and quiet reading could happen behind the closed door. Mia still sometimes wanted total silence, while Leo still interpreted a closed door as an invitation. A short daily check-in let us adjust the plan without turning every small disagreement into a family summit.
Open shelves had been my choice, partly because they looked generous and partly because I liked displaying things. Andrew preferred baskets that could hide clutter. We kept one open book shelf and gave each child a lidded box for the toys they used most. Tidy still slipped away by afternoon, but the room recovered quickly because every object had a designated home.
What changed beyond the walls
Four months later, the study works better than I expected. Each child has a predictable place to do homework, read and store the things that follow them around the house. The guest room remains a guest room, which spared us from rearranging the entire house, and our crowded bedroom remains our bedroom rather than becoming a showroom. More importantly, the children now see that making a home involves planning, listening and giving something up.
It changed how Andrew and I worked together too. He became less bothered by visible play pieces and more willing to build storage solutions with me. I stopped treating children's input as a series of demands and started treating it as useful information. Neither of us would claim the project solved every conflict, but it gave us a practical way to talk about needs before frustration turned into noise.
The room is not perfectly kept, the two desks do not match and one drawer still catches. I would choose some things differently, yet the family uses it. The lasting change was not the green paint or the mustard chair; it was the children learning that their preferences can shape a home, while learning that a shared home works when everyone gives ground. The room did not become flawless. It became theirs.